Unoffical empeg BBS

Quick Links: Empeg FAQ | RioCar.Org | Hijack | BigDisk Builder | jEmplode | emphatic
Repairs: Repairs

Topic Options
#157614 - 28/04/2003 11:40 IBM vs. Toshiba (Which 60GB to buy)
Fastrack
member

Registered: 29/10/2001
Posts: 137
Loc: Toronto, Ontario Canada
Hi all, I'm trying to decide which 60GB drive to buy.

I can get:
Toshiba MK6022GAX for $349 (16MB Buffer, 5,400rpm)
Toshiba MK6021GAS for $279 (2MB Buffer.. 4,200rpm)
or the
IBM 07N8328 for $509!!!!!!!!!!!

The IBM is almost twice the price. Any idea how the Toshiba will work out for me? I've read some of the posts (Using the search function... hehe). It seems the Toshiba is fairly good


Edited by Fastrack (28/04/2003 11:47)
_________________________
Ben Rio Car 10GB + 60GB Toshiba ([green]Green[/green]) - Serial # 30102833

Top
#157615 - 28/04/2003 12:16 Re: IBM vs. Toshiba (Which 60GB to buy) [Re: Fastrack]
tfabris
carpal tunnel

Registered: 20/12/1999
Posts: 31602
Loc: Seattle, WA
Assuming you mean to buy them for your car player and not your laptop...

As it says in the Drive Upgrade Guide, get the cheaper one. The speed of the faster and more expensive one will be wasted on the car player.

Exact quote:

Disk drive access speed isn't a factor, since the player uses an aggressive caching algorithm that leaves the disks spun down most of the time. Any modern laptop hard disk should be fast enough, and you will not notice any speed increase by purchasing a faster disk drive. In fact, if choosing between a fast drive and a slower drive, the slower drive is probably the better choice because it will most likely be cheaper and produce less heat. Your biggest concern will be the price/capacity trade-off.
_________________________
Tony Fabris

Top
#157616 - 28/04/2003 12:28 Re: IBM vs. Toshiba (Which 60GB to buy) [Re: Fastrack]
Jerz
addict

Registered: 13/07/2002
Posts: 634
Loc: Jesusland
If it's for the car player why not get an 80GB for $300.00?
http://www.googlegear.com/jsp/ProductDetail.jsp?ProductCode=100520


Top
#157617 - 28/04/2003 12:39 Re: IBM vs. Toshiba (Which 60GB to buy) [Re: Fastrack]
Redrum
old hand

Registered: 17/01/2003
Posts: 998
Here's a 60 Gig for $196 Don't know anything about the seller or the drive other than it's for a Laptop.

http://www.superwarehouse.com/Fujitsu_Mobile_MHS2060AT_60GB__Laptop_Hard_Drive/CA06272-B042/p/141744

Top
#157618 - 28/04/2003 12:49 Re: IBM vs. Toshiba (Which 60GB to buy) [Re: Redrum]
djc
enthusiast

Registered: 08/08/2000
Posts: 351
Loc: chicago
googlegear has the cheaper 60GB toshiba listed above for $184. why take chances?

--dan.


Edited by djc (28/04/2003 12:50)

Top
#157619 - 28/04/2003 13:56 Re: IBM vs. Toshiba (Which 60GB to buy) [Re: djc]
Fastrack
member

Registered: 29/10/2001
Posts: 137
Loc: Toronto, Ontario Canada
Wow quite a few responses, quick

I forgot to mention those prices are in Canadian Funds.. hehe. My main question was the reliability of the IBM vs. Toshiba for the Rio Car. And the noise which each create, etc.. etc..

Now would the more on board cache 16MB vs 2MB help with the RIO car? I'm assuming it probably wouldn't..
_________________________
Ben Rio Car 10GB + 60GB Toshiba ([green]Green[/green]) - Serial # 30102833

Top
#157620 - 29/04/2003 02:34 Re: IBM vs. Toshiba (Which 60GB to buy) [Re: Fastrack]
pupvogel
journeyman

Registered: 29/08/2000
Posts: 96
Loc: Hamburg, Germany
I had some trouble with Toshiba-drives in winter.
They wouldn't start up on first boot after a cold night in the car, so I had to restart my empeg a few times.
I never had that with IBM drives.

Thought this might be an issue in Canada...

Top
#157621 - 29/04/2003 05:05 Re: IBM vs. Toshiba (Which 60GB to buy) [Re: pupvogel]
juenk
journeyman

Registered: 12/01/2002
Posts: 84
Loc: Waardenburg, The Netherlands
> I had some trouble with Toshiba-drives in winter.
> They wouldn't start up on first boot after a cold night in the car,
> so I had to restart my empeg a few times.

Identical experience here in the Netherlands, with a 40Gb Toshiba as primary drive. No problems at ambient temperatures, however sub-zero often reboot required during startup. Probably due to too slow drive spinup at low temps at boot time.

J.
_________________________
Empeg M2A Blue # 010101908 80Gb
Empeg M2A Blue # 030102771 with backlight buttons - Need repair (IDE cable connection on main board) - volunteers?

Top
#157622 - 30/04/2003 15:17 Re: IBM vs. Toshiba (Which 60GB to buy) [Re: pupvogel]
cwillenbrock
enthusiast

Registered: 30/12/2000
Posts: 249
Loc: Dover, NJ
I'm about to throw my Toshiba 60 GB drive out the friggin window. I had what seemed to be the same problem, but seems to have evolved into something worse. The drive is terribly fluky now indoor at room temperature (in my empeg).

If you want it, just be outside my window in the next few minutes.

I'm thinking I might just get that 80 GB to replace it...
_________________________
- Chris Orig. Empeg Queue position 2

Top