Yes, Replay has added very compelling new features but my understanding is the basic PVR functionality is largely unchanged. The just-in-time scheduling, poor conflict management, and wasteful guaranteed space concept are still present.

I would like nothing better than for Replay to move to a predictive scheduler and simpler FIFO space management scheme. I love TiVo but I have no allegiance to it beyond my preference for it versus it's competitors. It would be great to have Replay's 2nd gen features combined with a more elegant PVR engine.

-Dylan