I might point out that the Replay product in that review is the previous generation (and unlike Tivo, the latest RTV has a LOT of new features and enhancements).

I won't comment on the scheduling because I have neither a Tivo nor a RTV at home right now. You have to live with these things to form a meaningful opinion. I know that most Replay owners are quite passionate about the "Replay way" over the "Tivo way" and I would doubt whether either system is totally flawed or totally perfect.

The RTV roadmap over the coming months and years is extremely exciting so I'm going to poll your opinion again in a while

</commercial>

Rob