It is a bitch to set up, but that is why it is so powerful... you can configure the heck out of it. Once you do, all you have to do is his the "mp3" button each time you pop in a CD. That's pretty simple. I paid for AudioGrabber too and still use EAC.

EAC has no issues with WinXP or NT or 2000. All you have to do is install an ASPI driver.