My HR10-250, the HDDirecTiVo, has died. It constantly shuts down with an overheat message, despite the fact that it's clearly not overheating. So now I have a quandary as to what to do.

I can lease a PVR from DirecTV, but it's not a TiVo, and I have to start another 2-year contract. I could find a replacement HR10-250, conceivably. I could drop DirecTV and get cable, where I could either pay for their non-TiVo, or pay a little bit extra for CableCARD access and get an (expensive) Series 3 TiVo. This would have the added benefit of getting me a better HD signal, as I currently have to watch HD OTA, and the transmitters are on the other side of the county.

Right now I'm leaning towards getting a new HR10-250, mostly because it's the easiest choice. Does anyone have any thoughts on the matter?